Showing posts with label Fantasy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fantasy. Show all posts

Monday, February 29, 2016

The Girl Who Could Silence the Wind by Meg Medina


Grades 5 and up--
Rooted in folklore with hints of mystery, magical realism and young love, The Girl Who Could Silence the Wind by Meg Medina tells the story of a small town that believes that one of their own has the power to change their futures, but for her, the pressure has become too much and she has to make a decision to


Intended audience:
According to Medina’s site, she aimed to write a telenovela style story for kids of all ages. I would say more specifically upper elementary students, boys and girls, Spanish speakers.


Audience to whom it may appeal: I think that the novel may appeal to kids and adults alike, those who are interested in a coming of age tale with a few twists and turns. It may also appeal to those interested in learning about magical realism and perhaps those interested in studying the Spanish language.


Strengths: The time and place of the tale is obscure enough that it could be anywhere at anytime which lends it to a unique experience for each and every reader. Its timeless themes of  family, perseverance and love make for a relatable read for all types of readers.


Weaknesses:  While the obscurity of the setting may be enjoyable for readers with strong imaginative skills, some might find the lack of descriptive language hard to picture and follow. There is a sprinkling of Spanish phrases throughout the novel that might discourage readers with no prior knowledge of the language or cultural practices.

VERDICT: An allegory for finding the balance between family and following your heart, this novel would be an excellent addition to an elementary or middle school library for students seeking a story with soul.

Monday, February 1, 2016

Shadowshaper by Daniel Jose Older

Grades 6 and up--

This novel was unlike anything I've read before. It is part realistic fiction, part spirituality narrative, part fantasy, part romance, the list goes on. 
Sierra is an admirable, witty heroine. She talks a mile a minute, paints stunning murals in the city late into the night and has a family secret that she can't quite figure out. For some mysterious reason, her elderly abuelo (grandfather) who hasn't spoken in months starts muttering "lo siento" (I'm sorry) and Sierra wants to know why. Her adventure takes her into a “thrilling collision of artistry and spirituality” (47) that shows young women can be just as powerful as men in any realm. I found myself admiring Sierra for her courage and laughing as she and her friends dealt with every day teenager angst alongside issues of life and death (think Hunger Games or Divergent with a spiritual twist). VERDICT: I think this magical book would make a great addition to any middle or high school media center. It has the power to grab the unsuspecting reader and hold on for the ride, meanwhile exposing him or her to issues worth discussing: race, identity, family, culture, art, heritage, and the power of art to transform relationships.

Monday, November 2, 2009

Airborn by Kenneth Oppel

Now this is what I call fantasy. Oppel takes us on a journey of mystical creatures, fantastic ships that ride on air, and gives us an epic battle that forces us to the edge of our seats. The best part of this book was that I was able to suspend my disbelief in order to enjoy the book and this is what makes a quality fantasy text. I loved this book. I was completely enthralled by the majestic nature of the airship and loved imagining every element Oppel described. To top off this incredible setting and description of this fantastical story, Oppel also provides his reader with a humble, brave and likeable protagonist. His love and respect for the Aurora is what ensures the reader loves it too—the way in which he personifies it makes it an admirable character of its own! The best part of Matt Cruse’s character is his respect for the rules and regulations of the ship—his adherence to the tradition and structure of the ship is what makes him so charming. When Kate invites him into her first-class cabin, he very politely declines: “Thank you, miss, but I can’t…I’m crew, not a first class passenger. I can’t just sit down in your stateroom!” (100). It is fitting, then, that he is skeptical of Kate’s conjecture of the magical creatures she believes her grandfather saw. However, like Mina in Skellig, Kate helps Matt to see and believe in things beyond reality. For many teenage boys, the undivided attention of a beautiful young girl would be appreciated and reciprocated, but Matt does not interpret it this way. He does not want anything to get in the way of his potential promotion, even if she is beautiful. The way he talks about the Aurora allows the reader to understand her as practically human—the one constant in Matt’s life, his home. He even uses female pronouns to describe the ship, and does everything in his power to protect her from any and all evil. “The idea of the ship being sawed up like a cadaver made me feel faint. My home, left in ruins, ever to fly again” (281).
The other element that I particularly enjoyed within this text was the author’s connections between the characters on an almost spiritual level. Matt is connected to Kate because he is the one who sights her grandfather; they are both connected to the pirates through the cloud cats and Kate’s grandfather’s presence on the island, etc. These types of connections make a complex text like this more enjoyable because they allow the reader to comprehend the text on an even deeper level.
Not only does Oppel provide us with a magical airship, but we meet mystical creatures and there is a battle to overtake the ship—all the excitement necessary to keep the reader engaged. Alongside all of the excitement, Oppel makes some pretty bold statements about the relationships between men and women and seems to be relatively feminist about the latter’s role in the world. He also comments on privilege versus hard work and the relationships between the classes. It is a smart, engaging and overall FUN book to read that I would recommend to young and old readers alike.

Skellig by David Almond


Even after turning the last page of the book two days ago, I am still trying to figure out what or who Skellig might be and I don’t really know how I feel about that—do I want a more involved explanation or am I satisfied with opened-ended ambiguity? Skellig was unlike any fantasy book I have ever experienced. To be honest, had it not been labeled fantasy, I think I would have enjoyed it more. I was expecting more fantastic elements than the book lent itself to, and this was disappointing. However, I enjoyed the mythical elements of the text and found myself in a state of wonder for a good majority of my reading. My favorite mythical element of the text was Michael’s ability to feel his baby sister’s heartbeat alongside his. This is such an important part of the book, because it demonstrates not only a kinship relationship between them, but a spiritual element as well. This is an aspect of the story that could not exist in a contemporary realistic fiction novel. Watching the simultaneous life-death teetering of both Skellig and the baby kept the novel in motion and tugged the reader’s heartstrings. Although I did not find myself particularly drawn to the character of Skellig—I found him to be quite whiny and less than charming—I found that I cared about him more because I felt that his existence was the only way that Michael’s sister could be saved, and that was the part of the story that I cared about.
At some points throughout the text, I felt as though the author might be attempting to reference to God or a religious figure and leave the interpretation up to his readers. This made for a very interesting interpretation. What is the author trying to say about God or angels? Are we intended to take a religious view of Skellig? How does this add or take away from the text?
Other fantasy texts I have read have been placed in entirely fictitious lands with entirely mythical and impossible creatures (i.e. Harry Potter and The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe). This is what I was expecting with Skellig and because of my expectation, I was disappointed. Had I gone into the text completely open, I think I may have taken away more from it.
Stepping back from the genre label of this text, I believe it has many positive aspects. First of all, the family dynamics in the story are incredibly heartwarming. What father-son duo is as close as Michael and his father? What boy is so in-tune with his emotions that he can feel his dying baby sister’s heartbeat alongside his own? At one point, when his sister’s heart stops for a moment, he feels it: “My heart’s stopped. Feel my heart. There’s nothing there” (149). I also appreciated the characterization of Mina and her mother. Mina is just as magical as Skellig (and ten times more charming), but she will not go away when the baby’s health is restored. Mina also teaches Michael the important lesson of not letting school get in the way of one’s education. He learns and remembers more during their explorations than a year of school possibly could. (An important thing to remember as an educator!) The mother-daughter relationship of Mina and her mother mirrors Michael and his father, and their welcoming home is one of the only ways Michael can survive the stress of his sister’s illness. The relationship between Michael and Mina is also particularly interesting because Mina allows for Michael to have these spiritual, magical experiences while Michael attempts to remain grounded in reality. After Skellig lifts them off of their feet and shows them their wings, Michael goes to the window. “‘What are you doing?’ she whispered. ‘Making sure the world’s still really there.’ I said’” (95). For him, the fantasy world is an element of his reality and he wants to have both. In the end it appears as though Skellig has served to bring Michael together with both Mina and his sister, and once he is gone, he has Mina and his baby sister to remind him of the fantastical elements—or extraordinary, as Mina would say—of everyday life.