Showing posts with label Historical Fiction. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Historical Fiction. Show all posts

Monday, April 4, 2016

Between Shades of Gray by Ruta Sepetys


Grades 8 and up--
Although Between Shades of Gray is a narrative capturing the horrors of WWII, it is unlike any other period novel I've ever read. This is the tale of the Baltics under the reign of Stalin, specifically tracing the journey of 15-year-old Lina and her family as they are deported from their home country (Lithuania) and dragged through Siberia into the frozen tundra if the Arctic Circle.

Intended audience: High school students interested in WWII history.

Audience to whom it may appeal: People of all ages, those interested in art, persevering through life's most unbearable struggles, family and history.

Strengths: The novels two biggest doorways are its story--wanting to know the fate of its characters-- and the characters themselves. Sepetys names few characters, Lina's family and three or four others, while the others are given nicknames such as “the bald man” and “the grouchy woman” which allows the reader to truly experience the events of the novel through Lina's eyes.

Weaknesses: The graphic descriptions of the conditions and violence they experience is quite intense and might be a turn-off for some readers. The ending is also quite abrupt and unexpected which might leave readers whose main doorway was characters a bit disappointed.

Special considerations: Prior knowledge of WWII history is critical to a full understanding of the context. Some Russian is used, but most often defined in context.

VERDICT: Due to the graphic nature and violence of the subject matter, this book best fits in a high school media center where students might be better able to contextualize the events of the novel. High school is also often the time during which WII is taught at length in history classes. This book will engage and likely elicit a visceral reaction from thoughtful readers. It is an important book to have on the shelf, not only for its unique perspective on a pivotal moment in history, but for the beauty and strength of its characters.

Tuesday, March 22, 2016

Uprising by Margaret Peterson Haddix




Grades 6 and up--
Uprising by Margaret Peterson Haddix tells the story and events prior to the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire of 1911. It tells the story through the lenses of three young women: Yetta, a Russian immigrant who’s passionate about women’s suffrage; Bella, an Italian immigrant, who feels lost without her family close by; and Jane, a girl with means but no real relationships to speak of. The story begins with Yetta and other women in the factory getting the idea to strike against their employers and ends with the fire, the rest you’ll have to find out on your own.
Intended audience: Young people interested in history, likely female, as all of the protagonists are girls.


Audience to whom it may appeal: This book would be an excellent companion text to a historical unit of study, in which case it might appeal to boys and girls if given in context. I also think that this book appeals to adults, male and female. It is not particularly challenging in regard to reading level, but the history significance and the subject has a wide appeal.


Strengths: Three interwoven stories from varying perspectives made for an interesting read, especially those from very different backgrounds. The historical aspects were very accurate from what I’ve researched and the writing is accessible, but not at all dull.


Weaknesses: Some parts move a bit slow and those with little or no knowledge of the women’s suffrage movement might struggle given the lack of context provided. At the end--without giving anything away--there were a few too many plotlines that were wrapped up in a neat little “bow,” which contrasted with the overall style of the novel.


Special considerations: Could be an excellent compliment to a history unit on women’s suffrage or the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire. Also promotes open and honest discussion about laborers rights as well as rights for immigrants.

VERDICT: I would absolutely add this to a middle or high school collection for its historical value, its unique style and the way it helps reveal the struggles of immigrants, women, and the working class in a way that is still extremely relevant.

Wednesday, December 9, 2009

Maus by Art Spiegelman


Art Spiegelman's father Vladek is a survivor of the Holocaust. Maus is the retelling of his experiences before, during and after the Holocaust. Set in Vladek's home over a number of afternoons, the story follows the thread of the father and son's conversation and covers everything from Vladek's romantic relationships, his wife (and Art's mother)'s suicide, to his absolutely terrifying experiences in Auschwitz. Spiegelman is an artist and the text is written in graphic novel form in which each of the groups of people is represented by a different animal. It is a new take on a story often told in a traditional novel style.

Overall, I cannot say that I particularly enjoyed the novel, though I can see its value. Although I have not read many graphic novels, I will say that I enjoyed all of them more than I did Maus. For some reason I couldn't get into the story. Perhaps it was the fact that there were multiple plot lines occurring simultaneously, or that it was so non-linear? I am not sure. However, I do see how Maus could be a useful text in a middle school or high school language arts class. Sporadically including graphic novels is a great way to "spice up" the curriculum and keep your students on their toes. It would be a good text to pair with perhaps The Diary of Anne Frank or Night as it would give an alternate perspective (the Polish experience) and present visual images to elicit potential discussion.

Sunday, October 25, 2009

A Northern Light by Jennifer Donnelly


-->
After reading The Book Thief, I was taken aback by the power of books and language. To my extreme gratification, A Northern Light was equally invested in the incredible potential of the written and spoken word. Donnelly’s book is beautifully written and important. Her playfulness with language, her ability to switch from past to present smoothly, in addition to her feminist twinge made this book an awesome, enlightening read.
To be honest, I have never been one for historical fiction mainly because I cannot stand the ways in which people (particularly women and people of color) have been historically marginalized. This is not to say that this has been resolved, but it is just more evident and shocking in early twentieth century texts. This book was a great experience for me personally because it showed me the injustices I feared, but fought against them. The fact that Mattie is the first in her family to get her high school diploma, her best friend is not only male, but African-American, and that she has a job outside of the home to support her family are all elements of a story from 1906 that I did not expect.
I loved seeing 16-year-old Mattie go through all of the typical teenage trials and tribulations, but in an entirely different setting. She argues with her siblings, fights with her father, hates her name, falls in love, experiences the tug of sexual desire and doesn’t know what to do with it (who does?), and plays made up games and a secret language with her best friend. Like any teenage female, Mattie compares herself to other girls: “Belinda is a pretty name. It feels like meringue in your mouth or a curl of sugar on snow. Not like Matt. Matt is the sound of knots in a dog’s coat or something you wipe your feet on” (51). She becomes giddy with emotion when Royal kisses her, but fears she will lose her independence or intelligence: “Can a girl be unmanned? I wondered. By a boy? Can she be unbrained? (78). One element of the story that I felt was incredibly different from most teenagers experiences in modern day, was the compulsion Mattie felt to support her family’s dreams, rather than her own. This pull between family and independence was incredibly powerful and really made me think about what I would do in the same situation. For Mattie, is a matter of love versus language, love being marriage and family—her expected role, and language being following her dreams of going to Barnard to study and write literature. “I wondered if all those things were the best things to have or if it was better to have words and stories…Nobody I knew had both” (96-97).
The way the book is structured with alternating chapters focusing on Mattie’s story and Grace’s, we can see the way in which the latter affects the former. While she is falling in love with books and boys, she is also reading the story of a woman who gives her entire self to her man, only to be left completely alone and eventually killed. This affects the way Mattie views relationships and allows her to see that things are not always as they seem: sometimes people will use and abuse you for their own benefit, without caring at all. Understanding this allows her the courage to break off the engagement to Royal, whom she has realized is using her to gain land on her father’s property.
Both of these plot lines allow Mattie to continually develop her love of reading and her passion for the story: “There were lives in those books, and deaths. Families and friends and lovers and enemies. Joy and despair, jealousy, envy, madness, and rage…I could almost hear the characters inside, murmuring and jostling, impatient for me to open the cover and let them out” (200). The words in the letters and the books are what allow her to escape the life she doesn’t want and free her from a destiny that is inopportune. One again, the power of texts prevails, what English teacher can argue with that? Happy reading!

The Book Thief by Markus Zusak


-->
“Where’s the fight? He wondered. Where’s the will to hold on? Of course, at thirteen, he was a little excessive in his harshness. He had not looked something like me in the face. Not yet” (189).
This quote sticks in my mind because it is so symbolic of the text as a whole. This book is constantly asking: What is worth surviving for? Everyone is the story chooses survival over resignation for one reason, each individually unique: for Liesel it is books and her papa, for Rudy it is a kiss from Liesel, for Hans it is his family and accordion, for Ilsa Hermann—the mayor’s wife—it is the opportunity to provide for Liesel what no one else can, etc. Written from the voice of “Death” personified, the stories embedded in the novel give the reader an opportunity to see how each character interprets life and what he or she deems indispensible. This is an incredibly powerful structure for a book and I have no doubt that other readers were as affected as I. The style of the narrative took away the complexity and boiled life down to its most simplistic elements. What is needed to live a life worth living? At some points in the novel, survival become literal—with bread and coffee grounds, but in others survival is grounded in the human soul. Liesel does not differentiate between books and food—they are equally vital: “‘You hungry?’ Rudy asked. Liesel replied. ‘Starving.’ For a book” (287). This book allows the reader to see the true power of various art forms like music, writing, drawing, and reading. These are not just extracurriculars! They are essential to life.
Liesel’s adoration and thievery of books is such an interesting and effective way to show the Holocaust through a child’s eyes. She not only sees injustice in the physical mistreatment of Jews, but she is able to see the ways that language has been taken away and limited for them. She is able to understand the power dynamic in a whole new way based on her understanding of language. It was so refreshing to meet a young person who truly perceived the power of words. She sees the complexity of language and the ways it can be used to both free the mind AND manipulate it. This power through the manipulation of words culminated beautifully when Max took Mein Kampf and physically covered its pages in white paint in order to write over them—the ultimate subversion. Not only was Max taking away the power of Hitler’s words by deleting them, he was literally replacing them with his own language. This was so incredible: it gives me chills to recall.
After Max has been walked to Dachau and her papa has gone to war, Liesel takes her anger out on words: “Soon there was nothing but scraps of words littered between her legs and all around her. The words. Why did they have to exist? Without them, there wouldn’t be any of this. Without words, the Fuhrer has nothing” (521). What an insight for a young child!
There was so much to this book, it is challenging to discuss all of the elements I found to be interesting, important or perception-altering, but I think the role of the narrator in the text was extremely pivotal to my understanding of the novel. I can honestly say I’ve never read (or cared to read) in which “death” plays a primary role but I was pleasantly surprised, by the outcome of this “character” in the text. “Death” has been personified in movies, books and on television as an evil, malicious being, with strong dislike for happiness or life-giving energy. This book completely flipped this idea on its head, and made me think about dying in an entirely different way. Death does not relish in taking life, death wants to understand people better, death wants to be fought and not freely accepted. With so much more to it than I can express adequately, this book is a must read for everyone, take the time to step into Liesel’s world and be forever changed. Happy reading!