Synopsis: As the title implies, this graphic novel is indeed a rendition of Macbeth, as performed by animals. Macbeth is one of Shakespeare’s most famous tragedies about a power hungry man in Denmark who wants to be king and will do almost anything to get the job. This version is no different, except for in place of brutal Shakespearean murder, there is the circle of life (animals eating other animals)...
Intended Audience: Grades 2-5, those interested in graphic novels, animals, and learning about Shakespeare
But it might also appeal to: Middle school students who might better be equipped for the animals eating animals bloody parts,adults and teens who are familiar with the original might enjoy this goofy spoof on Shakespeare’s classic.
Strengths: The illustrations are stunning and the writing makes Shakespeare’s story much easier to understand. For those who understand it, the parody is quite funny as well.
Weaknesses: It is hard to know what this book would be like for someone who hasn’t read (or taught!) Macbeth. Not sure that the story would be as entertaining for those without prior knowledge of the original.
Special considerations: Based on Shakespeare’s Macbeth, some references might be lost on a younger audience, some bloody scenes where animals eat other animals, could be used as a companion text to the original in a high school classroom.
Verdict: The Stratford Zoo’s version of Macbeth would add a new element to any elementary media center: a book about Shakespeare! Given the level of most Shakespearean plays, most students don’t interact with them until high school--or perhaps late middle--but this book allows for an easier access point and introduction to the author. It would also be a great addition to a high school media center where it might be accessed alongside the classic play.
Synopsis: The Invention of Hugo Cabret is a mysterious graphic novel about a young boy living in a Paris train station. He is an orphan and steals from local vendors to survive, but he is working on a project--a secret project--that no one can find, so he must be careful, but then someone catches him stealing…
Intended audience: Children ages 9-12, readers who like graphic novels, mysteries
But it might also appeal to: Adults, children younger than nine reading it with an adult, or teenagers interested in graphic novels, mysteries, mechanical toys, Paris or history.
Strengths: The book is almost exactly 1/2 illustrations and 1/2 text, which allows for a stronger reader to have a more visual experience, while a reader who appreciates comics and graphic novels will have an immediate "in." The mystery keeps the audience's attention to the very end.
Weaknesses: While the artwork is stunning, it is limited to black and white which was slightly disappointing. The language of the text, while mostly simple, does include a bit of challenging lingo related to the keeping of clocks and other mechanical contraptions. In this case, an adult reader who could "translate" might be helpful to a younger reader.
Special considerations: This is a physically LARGE book, which could be intimidating to a reader who has traditionally read shorter chapter books, however the actual text takes up very little space on the page and reads quickly when partnered with vivid images. There is also a film, which could be used for a comparison/contrast activity. There is also quite a bit of historical context in the novel that could serve extension opportunities for students.
Verdict: This magical novel would be an excellent addition to a elementary, middle or high school library has it has the potential to reach a wide variety of readers interested in art, poetic writing, mystery and interesting characters.
This stunning graphic novel is compact, but powerful. The artwork is similar to the stark black and white drawings of Marjane Satrapi’s Persepolis and illustrate the divided world in which she lives: Beirut, Lebanon in the 1980s and 1990s. Written like a list poem, with each page or so beginning with “I Remember,” Abirached tells the story of her life growing up in a war zone.
Intended audience: Young adults interested in history.
Audience to whom it may appeal: I think this book could appeal to upper elementary students to grandparents, of all genders, races and religions. Its universal themes of memory and perseverance through struggle have the potential to provide connections for many.
Strengths: The artwork is visually very appealing. The solid black and white images are simple but captivating. The poetic style and repetition makes it accessible for a wider variety of audiences.
Weaknesses: Without much historical context, this book might be hard to understand, but it can also stand on its own as a story of a young girl’s life and all of the things she experienced. Although the prose and dialogue are relatively simplistic, there are historical and cultural references that will likely be missed by students with little background knowledge.
Special considerations: The book is a companion to A Game for Swallows which focuses on one particular night during war time.
VERDICT: This book would make a great addition to either the graphic novel or history section of any upper elementary through high school media center. The accessible format will appeal to lower readers, while the historical content might entice higher level readers to try a new format: graphic novel.
Grades 6 and up--
Let me start off by saying, I'm not really a graphic novel person, nor am I into choose-your-own-adventures. However... Meanwhile by Jason Shiga is BOTH of these things and was SO MUCH FUN to read. While I'm a person who loves a long novel with character development for days, I can absolutely see why someone (anyone, really!) would want to pick up this book.
In this extremely interactive graphic novel, Jimmy starts out on a seemingly ordinary afternoon, in search of an ice cream cone. But this is only the beginning. Once you choose chocolate or vanilla, the adventure really begins. Each choice leads you to a new page, new characters and new adventures. While one page might just take you home for a nice relaxing evening, another might give the opportunity to use a time machine or a "killitron" (read to find out more).
The beauty in this book is in its cleverness - it literally took almost 10 years to publish due to the complex nature of the structure! The comics are bright and accessible, once you figure out how to read it! You could read this book in 10 minutes or spend an entire weekend exploring its many possibilties.
VERDICT: A must-have in middle and high school media centers, it has an extremely wide appeal to young and old, male and female, as well as high and low readers. (Though I might include a how-to-read guide along with it.) Also - though the pages are thick, this particular book requires a lot of tender care to ensure the tabs (and thus story) stay intact!
Art Spiegelman's father Vladek is a survivor of the Holocaust. Maus is the retelling of his experiences before, during and after the Holocaust. Set in Vladek's home over a number of afternoons, the story follows the thread of the father and son's conversation and covers everything from Vladek's romantic relationships, his wife (and Art's mother)'s suicide, to his absolutely terrifying experiences in Auschwitz. Spiegelman is an artist and the text is written in graphic novel form in which each of the groups of people is represented by a different animal. It is a new take on a story often told in a traditional novel style.
Overall, I cannot say that I particularly enjoyed the novel, though I can see its value. Although I have not read many graphic novels, I will say that I enjoyed all of them more than I did Maus. For some reason I couldn't get into the story. Perhaps it was the fact that there were multiple plot lines occurring simultaneously, or that it was so non-linear? I am not sure. However, I do see how Maus could be a useful text in a middle school or high school language arts class. Sporadically including graphic novels is a great way to "spice up" the curriculum and keep your students on their toes. It would be a good text to pair with perhaps The Diary of Anne Frank or Night as it would give an alternate perspective (the Polish experience) and present visual images to elicit potential discussion.
From the moment I picked up American Born Chinese, I was excited to read it cover to cover. I had paged through the novel looking at the pictures and reading the inside flaps, but I couldn’t wait to dive into the story itself. I knew that the book was divided into three parts and going into the book, I was most excited to read about the story of Jin Wang: the partially autobiographical, realistic fiction portion of the novel. I was hesitant to read what appeared to be a folktale and a blatantly racist representation of a Chinese individual. However, I was determined to give the other two parts a fair shot and I was pleasantly surprised.
Although I taught my intersession course on comics and graphic novels, I remain to have very minimal experience with visual texts. At first, I will admit, I thought that reading graphic novels was a little like cheating. How was I supposed to “use my imagination” if the pictures were already there? Where was the challenge? However, teaching my intersession class and reading this novel really helped me to understand the unique role of the graphic novel. Yang was able to represent so much more of his message with pictures that would have been impossible or just plain confusing if written out in language. Given that the story is all about identity and the diversity of cultures, it seemed fitting that he use a medium that is universal: pictures. And the way they have been so beautifully drawn, no translation is needed whatsoever.
The story thread of the Monkey King was really interesting to me. Having no familiarity with Chinese folktales, it made me want to learn more. I felt this element of the story showed the pride Yang has in his heritage while the other two showed the difficulty he had with combining his heritage with his newfound culture; a challenge for so many adolescents (and adults) today. Now that I have read this novel and seen one version of the monkey king tale, I plan on reading more about the Chinese folktale.
At first I was completely shocked at Yang’s blunt use of racial stereotyping in the character of Chin-kee. I thought to myself, “how could someone who is promoting pride in his heritage be so blatantly racist in his portrayal of his own culture?” However, it didn’t take long to realize Yang’s purpose: blatant stereotyping would stand out and make readers think. Yang is aware that this language is used to describe and mock Chinese people on a regular basis and he wants his readers to see what this looks and feels like. It is extremely offensive and I truly believe that was Yang’s intent. It really made me think about the stereotypes I see and hear on a regular basis and what I might do to contradict those racist actions. I really appreciated his bold choice to use a stereotypical character to get his ideas across.
As far as the medium goes, I feel that a graphic novel was a great choice for this particular trio of stories. Yang was able to easily shift from story to story with a simple shift of background. His ability to use visual cues to illustrate emotion and inner thoughts really helped me to understand the characters on an entirely different level. In a way, the increase in visual cues allowed me to have a deeper comprehension of the story as well as the changes each of the characters experiences throughout the novel.
Overall, I really enjoyed the book. Yang is an incredible storyteller through images and ideas and I am grateful he was willing to put his thoughts and feelings on paper so that others might begin to understand his experience. I would highly recommend this book, particularly to someone who has little or no experience with graphic novels. Happy reading!