Showing posts with label Nonfiction. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Nonfiction. Show all posts

Sunday, April 10, 2016

Lucy Long Ago by Catherine Thimmesh



Grades 4 and up--


Lucy Long Ago tells the story of one of the biggest scientific discoveries of the 20th century: the uncovering of “Lucy”: the “oldest, most complete fossil skeleton ever found.” The book begins with the discovery of the bones in 1974 and traces the scientific research that followed. It is an intriguing combination of science and imagination written in an engaging narrative style.


Intended audience: Elementary or middle school students interested in evolution, science, anthropology or just generally curious about the world we live in.


Audience to whom it may appeal: This book has the potential to engage young and old audience alike with it’s clear explanations, vivid graphics and images and accessible story structure.


Strengths: Though the book is nonfiction, it is written in a narrative style so it has the potential to appeal to a variety of readers as informative as well as entertaining. The pictures and graphics are well done and help the reader to better understand the scientific research that went into Lucy’s discovery and subsequent theories about the history of humanity.


Weaknesses: Some of the science jargon could be a bit off-putting to lower level readers or those with minimal science education. In a way, it might be considered a challenge to creationism, which might bring about requests for removal in certain districts.


Special considerations: This book very much describes science consistent with Darwin (and others’) theory of evolution and could potentially face challenges from parents who prefer their children to focus on their religious teachings of creationism.

VERDICT: I think Lucy Long Ago would make an excellent addition to any elementary, middle or even high school library. Its unique content, vivid graphics and images and narrative style make it a great book for kids of all ages.

Saturday, April 9, 2016

Sex: A Book for Teens by Nikol Hasler


Ages 15 and up--


Intended audience: This book is written for teenagers who are curious about sex, whether or not they are having it or plan to have it.


Audience to whom it may appeal: Although the content may appeal to a younger audience, I think would be difficult to convince a K-8 or younger library to carry this book. It could also appeal to adults who have lingering questions about sex. (I learned a lot!)


Strengths: This book is very straightforward with facts, figures and clear explanations. It is also inclusive of various sexualities and gender identities. The author incorporates humor as well, which could help to alleviate some of the awkwardness of reading such a book.  There are also many resources (websites, phone numbers) for learning more about safe sex including the possibility of STIs and teen pregnancy.


Weaknesses: The cover, style, and content of this book could be construed as giving permission or even promoting teens to have sex. There is also the potential for bits and pieces (chapter titles, cartoons) of the book to be taken out of context and misconstrued. Although the purpose of the book is to inform, I can foresee potential challenges to its forthright (and potentially encouraging) nature.


Special considerations: Clear explanations of sex in all of its variations including GLBT, as well as thorough objective descriptions of the spectrum of gender identities. This may be a book that, although not labeled “reference,” might not wander far from its shelf, though incurring frequent perusal from curious patrons.  

VERDICT: Although the chance of challenge might be high, I would still promote the selection of this book in a high school media center. It is a humorous look at an awkward topic and has the potential to be extremely informative in an area that is often considered taboo. I think that the (mostly) objective explanatory style of the book would be an excellent addition to the library collection.

Tuesday, March 8, 2016

I Remember Beirut by Zeina Abirached


Grades 6 and up--

This stunning graphic novel is compact, but powerful. The artwork is similar to the stark black and white drawings of Marjane Satrapi’s Persepolis and illustrate the divided world in which she lives: Beirut, Lebanon in the 1980s and 1990s. Written like a list poem, with each page or so beginning with “I Remember,” Abirached tells the story of her life growing up in a war zone.


Intended audience: Young adults interested in history.


Audience to whom it may appeal: I think this book could appeal to upper elementary students to grandparents, of all genders, races and religions. Its universal themes of memory and perseverance through struggle have the potential to provide connections for many.


Strengths: The artwork is visually very appealing. The solid black and white images are simple but captivating. The poetic style and repetition makes it accessible for a wider variety of audiences.


Weaknesses: Without much historical context, this book might be hard to understand, but it can also stand on its own as a story of a young girl’s life and all of the things she experienced. Although the prose and dialogue are relatively simplistic, there are historical and cultural references that will likely be missed by students with little background knowledge.


Special considerations: The book is a companion to A Game for Swallows which focuses on one particular night during war time.

VERDICT: This book would make a great addition to either the graphic novel or history section of any upper elementary through high school media center. The accessible format will appeal to lower readers, while the historical content might entice higher level readers to try a new format: graphic novel.

Monday, November 23, 2009

A Long Way Gone by Ishmael Beah

Talk about a visceral reaction. This book was incredibly terrifying. But, I’m glad I read it because there is no cure for ignorance besides education. A Long Way Gone is an amazing example of a text that promotes social change in an extremely powerful way. There is no way that a documentary on child soldiers or a newspaper article could have the power this book has. Seeing war through the innocent eyes of a child is the most authentic, honest portrayal of war there is. The most powerful aspect of the text was the changes Ishmael experiences throughout the book. It is awful to watch him be stripped of his innocence one page at a time. At the beginning, we see him responding as a civilian: “I turned away, and my eyes caught the smashed head of another man…I felt nauseated. Everything began to spin around me. One of the soldiers was looking at me, chewing something and smiling. He took a drink…‘You will get used to it, everybody does eventually,’ he said” (100). At that point in the text, I too felt sick to my stomach and I remember thinking “there is no way he will get used to this.”

However, we see the power brainwashing and propaganda can have on someone who has lost all hope. During training, the soldiers are reminded of their loss and coerced into allegiance with the government: “Visualize the enemy, the rebels who killed your parents, your family, and those who are responsible for everything that has happened” (112). Their leaders tell them, “Our job is a serious one and we have the most capable soldiers, who will do anything to defend this country” (123).
It was absolutely horrifying watching Ishmael fall into these (what I thought to be obvious) traps. It makes sense that he had to distance himself from his actions and be almost empty, similar to an abuse victim: “I just sat with my head in my hands, thoughtless” (109).

For a good part of the book, I must admit I was angry with Ishmael. I did not understand how he could transform so quickly from an innocent child into a soulless killer. However, I pushed through and knew deep down that what I really felt was remorse and sadness for his loss of innocence. He was truly a victim. This is absolutely devastating. This particular passage sticks out in my head: “I didn’t feel a thing for him, didn’t think that much about what I was doing. I just waited for the corporal’s order. The prisoner was simply another rebel who was responsible for the death of my family, as I had come to truly believe” (124). In hindsight, Ishmael is realizing that he had created excuses for himself and pointed out his reasoning for completing such terrible acts. The fact that I know he was a victim of a horrible crime does not eliminate the goose bumps from the back of my neck as a re-read this passage.
Horrifying memories reenacted aside, this book was extremely powerful for me. Having little to no knowledge of the situation in Sierra Leone, this book gave me a very personal account of the horrors that occurred there during the civil war.

And last but not least, I was so incredibly grateful for Esther, Ishmael’s nurse. She showed an incredible amount of compassion for Ishmael and was willing to step completely outside of her comfort zone in order to help him. She helped him to begin his lengthy but crucial recovery in a very powerful way. I would highly recommend this book to anyone, young or old, for it teaches an amazing lesson about the resilience of the human spirit. Happy reading!

Sunday, November 15, 2009

Shipwreck at the Bottom of the World by Jennifer Armstrong

Armstrong’s vivid imagery and incredible story telling drew me into the story of the Endurance from the very first page. Being that I am ordinarily a huge fan of fiction, I was hesitant to pick up Shipwreck, but I was pleasantly surprised. Armstrong does an incredible job of weaving together pictures from the trek, diary entries from the crew, historical facts from the period seamlessly while telling the story in the style of a regular novel. Although she gives us the end of the story at the beginning (and those familiar with the Shackleton’s tale, already know!) she writes in such a way that the reader does not care to put it down. It is not “what happens” to the men or how the book ends—we already know that, it’s history! —but it is the journey, and as any experienced reader knows, this is the making of a good story.

Armstrong’s ability to create a documentary style story that is personal, intriguing, and emotional made it hard to believe she wasn’t there. I felt as though some of the emotions expressed in the story could only have been recorded by a member of the crew. Armstrong keeps her reader emotionally engaged in the experience by using similar language as the crew. The ship becomes a part of the crew, a character in the story: “Struggling out onto the ice, the crew witnessed the last of Endurance, a mile and a half away, as her bows went under. Then the ship dived quickly and the ice closed over her with a rush…The long-delayed death of their ship sent a wave of sadness and depression over the crew. While she lasted, Endurance had been a visible link to the world they once knew” (59).

In the past when I have read nonfiction texts, I have been disappointed by their lack of focus on the people, the players in the drama themselves. I was concerned that this text would primarily give me detailed information on the weather, the ship, the wildlife etc, but leave out the most interesting part: the adventurers! However, I was not disappointed. Armstrong’s incredible, no doubt intensely involved research provided her with stories galore to share about the men that made up Shackleton’s Endurance. I could imagine nearly every one of the men with their own unique quirks and tastes and I could envision their arguments, practical jokes, and their celebrations of “the Ritz.” I must not forget to recognize Frank Hurley’s photography for these incredible images! There is one photo in the book in which the men are dressed for a variety show and one man is in blackface. At first I was shocked that this was included in a book published today, but then my concern quickly diminished when I noticed Armstrong’s informative description of the concept with subsequent disapproval: “The crewman on the left in ‘blackface’ illustrates a form of racial slur common to the era which no one today would tolerate” (38). This carefully composed commentary alongside a riveting story of survival is what makes this book great.

I feel that an excellent nonfiction text for young adults is comprised of factual information, narrative, stimulating language and illustrations (either vivid descriptions or pictures themselves). Unfortunately, young adults often find history to be boring and it is up to educators and nonfiction authors to alter this perception. Nonfiction not only teaches the reader something, but asks questions too. What does this historical event teach us about the human experience? How will this concept affect our future? Etc. Jennifer Armstrong is one example of an author who has done this successfully. She has done her research; not only of Endurance and her men, but also of young adult writing. Her style includes engaging language that assumes a certain degree of knowledge, but also works to teach her reader new vocabulary in an interesting, non-condescending way. Her descriptions of the men, particularly Shackleton, beg the question: How do we nurture hope? What can this crew of determined, brave men teach us about the human condition?

Like Howard Zinn, Armstrong teaches history through the people who experienced it. Because of her dedication to creating such a reading experience, young adults, alongside their teachers and parents, will be drawn to this human story of struggle and perseverance.