Friday, June 10, 2016

Waiting by Kevin Henkes

Synopsis: Five animal toys sit on a windowsill, each of them waiting for something to occur. The book follows their life through the seasons and a variety of emotions.


Intended Audience: Beginning readers, K-1


But it might also appeal to: Younger children as a guided reading or read-aloud text as beautiful illustrations tell the majority of the story and invite imaginative thinking.




Strengths: Vivid illustrations of the animals and their window watching, but also their emotions as they watch what happens outside. Very minimal text leaves a lot of room for children to invite their imaginations into the reading. The characters’ interactions with each other and their “visitors” model how important it is to be welcoming and share what you have.



Weaknesses: The book seems to end right when the excitement begins, but perhaps that is a lesson about waiting...?






Special considerations: One of the “visitors” to the windowsill, a ceramic elephant, “stayed for a while, then he left and never returned.” This, next to the broken ceramic pieces of the elephant, sadly looked upon by two of the toys, could serve as a helpful segue when talking to children about something as small as a broken toy or as large as a lost loved one.


Verdict: Waiting would be a great fit for a media center serving students pre-k through first or second grade. Its simplicity and lovely visuals make it a delightful choice for a new reader or an adult reading to children.





Red: A Crayon's Story by Michael Hall

Synopsis: Spoiler alert! “Red” is a blue crayon with a red label. Everyone expects him to be great at drawing things like hearts and strawberries, but he keeps failing until a new friend asks him to do the unexpected....


Intended Audience: Pre K - grade 2


But it might also appeal to: Younger kids might enjoy as a read aloud, could be a good book for discussing identity and expectations with middle grade or YA readers.




Strengths: Sends a positive message about being true to yourself, colorful illustrations that look quite similar to typical crayon drawings and could be and exciting familiar feature for young readers. Demonstrates a healthy range of emotions for children (and crayons!).






Weaknesses: The text is quite small to leave room for the illustrations, but might be intimidating for new readers.





Special considerations: Although the basic message is about identity in general, this book could be used as a tool for teaching children about gender identity.




Verdict: Red tells a great story about getting to know yourself, a message that everyone can benefit from and should be available to be “red” by all audiences pre-k to adult.






The Stratford Zoo Midnight Revue Presents: Macbeth by Ian Lendler


Synopsis: As the title implies, this graphic novel is indeed a rendition of Macbeth, as performed by animals. Macbeth is one of Shakespeare’s most famous tragedies about a power hungry man in Denmark who wants to be king and will do almost anything to get the job. This version is no different, except for in place of brutal Shakespearean murder, there is the circle of life (animals eating other animals)...
Intended Audience: Grades 2-5, those interested in graphic novels, animals, and learning about Shakespeare

But it might also appeal to: Middle school students who might better be equipped for the animals eating animals bloody parts, adults and teens who are familiar with the original might enjoy this goofy spoof on Shakespeare’s classic.


Strengths: The illustrations are stunning and the writing makes Shakespeare’s story much easier to understand. For those who understand it, the parody is quite funny as well.


Weaknesses: It is hard to know what this book would be like for someone who hasn’t read (or taught!) Macbeth. Not sure that the story would be as entertaining for those without prior knowledge of the original.



Special considerations: Based on Shakespeare’s Macbeth, some references might be lost on a younger audience, some bloody scenes where animals eat other animals, could be used as a companion text to the original in a high school classroom.




Verdict: The Stratford Zoo’s version of Macbeth would add a new element to any elementary media center: a book about Shakespeare! Given the level of most Shakespearean plays, most students don’t interact with them until high school--or perhaps late middle--but this book allows for an easier access point and introduction to the author. It would also be a great addition to a high school media center where it might be accessed alongside the classic play.




Thursday, June 9, 2016

Morris Micklewhite and the Tangerine Dress by Christina Baldacchino, Illustrated by Isabelle Malenfant


Synopsis: Morris Micklewhite loves to play dress-up, especially if it means he can wear the tangerine dress in his classroom’s dress up chest. Unfortunately, the other kids don’t think it is okay for a boy to wear a dress, so his classmates pick on him. One day he decides to stay home because he is feeling bad about himself, but learns something very important about the tangerine dress...and himself.


Intended Audience: Pre-k to grade 2


But it might also appeal to: Upper elementary students, even middle school students when talking about identity and having courage to be different from your peers


Weaknesses: Although the book encourages Morris’ choice to wear the dress and be different, the fact that he was essentially being bullied by his classmates is never explicitly brought up and the fact that the positive message comes when he skips school for a day might be a bit confusing for kids.





Strengths: The illustrations are stunning and the story sends a positive message about being unique and also a more subtle message about how sometimes gender norms restrict kids’ ability to express themselves.


Special considerations: Although subtle, the message about gender norms could provide for an interesting parent-child or teacher-child conversation about how toys and clothes are chosen for kids of different genders.


Verdict: Any book that promotes creativity and imaginative play in the same way as Morris Micklewhite absolutely deserves a place on the shelf of a media center for kids of all ages. I would even argue a high school media center could benefit from its presence.

The Year of Billy Miller


Synopsis: The Year of Billy Miller follows Billy through his second grade year filled with an annoying (and sometimes cute) little sister, a teacher he's convinced doesn't like him, and the know-it-all girl in his class he can't seem to avoid. At first, it seems to Billy that it's going to be rough year, but then he gets his teacher to smile and he comes up with a plan...




Intended Audience: Children in grades 3-6, interested in books about school, family and friends

But it might also appeal to: Younger children doing a read aloud in class or with an adult, adults working with elementary age students, second graders - it is about second grade!

Strengths: Very realistic representations of classroom and family dynamics, Billy is a likable character who learns a lot of important lessons about being confident and learning to interact with others.

Weaknesses: The description of the book alludes to the bump on his head (he gets while visiting the Jolly Green Giant statue on summer break) playing a bigger role in the story than it actually does, which is a bit misleading. I thought the story might deal with a memory loss or injury, when really that played a small part.




Special considerations: Kevin Henkes has written MANY books for children of all ages, but this is the first Billy Miller text. The book takes place in Wisconsin with geographical references that might be of interest to midwesterners!



Verdict: This novel would make an excellent addition to the shelves of any media center up to middle grades. It is well written, entertaining and has a great message about family for readers of all kinds.












Sunday, May 22, 2016

The Invention of Hugo Cabret by Brian Selznick

Synopsis:  The Invention of Hugo Cabret is a mysterious graphic novel about a young boy living in a Paris train station. He is an orphan and steals from local vendors to survive, but he is working on a project--a secret project--that no one can find, so he must be careful, but then someone catches him stealing…


Intended audience: Children ages 9-12, readers who like graphic novels, mysteries


But it might also appeal to: Adults, children younger than nine reading it with an adult, or teenagers interested in graphic novels, mysteries, mechanical toys, Paris or history.
Strengths: The book is almost exactly 1/2 illustrations and 1/2 text, which allows for a stronger reader to have a more visual experience, while a reader who appreciates comics and graphic novels will have an immediate "in." The mystery keeps the audience's attention to the very end.
Weaknesses: While the artwork is stunning, it is limited to black and white which was slightly disappointing. The language of the text, while mostly simple, does include a bit of challenging lingo related to the keeping of clocks and other mechanical contraptions. In this case, an adult reader who could "translate" might be helpful to a younger reader.

Special considerations: This is a physically LARGE book, which could be intimidating to a reader who has traditionally read shorter chapter books, however the actual text takes up very little space on the page and reads quickly when partnered with vivid images. There is also a film, which could be used for a comparison/contrast activity. There is also quite a bit of historical context in the novel that could serve extension opportunities for students.



Verdict: This magical novel would be an excellent addition to a elementary, middle or high school library has it has the potential to reach a wide variety of readers interested in art, poetic writing, mystery and interesting characters.

Sunday, April 10, 2016

Lucy Long Ago by Catherine Thimmesh



Grades 4 and up--


Lucy Long Ago tells the story of one of the biggest scientific discoveries of the 20th century: the uncovering of “Lucy”: the “oldest, most complete fossil skeleton ever found.” The book begins with the discovery of the bones in 1974 and traces the scientific research that followed. It is an intriguing combination of science and imagination written in an engaging narrative style.


Intended audience: Elementary or middle school students interested in evolution, science, anthropology or just generally curious about the world we live in.


Audience to whom it may appeal: This book has the potential to engage young and old audience alike with it’s clear explanations, vivid graphics and images and accessible story structure.


Strengths: Though the book is nonfiction, it is written in a narrative style so it has the potential to appeal to a variety of readers as informative as well as entertaining. The pictures and graphics are well done and help the reader to better understand the scientific research that went into Lucy’s discovery and subsequent theories about the history of humanity.


Weaknesses: Some of the science jargon could be a bit off-putting to lower level readers or those with minimal science education. In a way, it might be considered a challenge to creationism, which might bring about requests for removal in certain districts.


Special considerations: This book very much describes science consistent with Darwin (and others’) theory of evolution and could potentially face challenges from parents who prefer their children to focus on their religious teachings of creationism.

VERDICT: I think Lucy Long Ago would make an excellent addition to any elementary, middle or even high school library. Its unique content, vivid graphics and images and narrative style make it a great book for kids of all ages.